Eight senators urge the STB to reject the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern merger as public comments close

A bipartisan group of eight senators asked the Surface Transportation Board on Wednesday to reject Union Pacific's purchase of Norfolk Southern, DTN reported Nov. 18. The letter, led by Sens. Tammy Baldwin (D-Wis.) and Roger Marshall (R-Kan.), argues the deal would sharply cut competition in freight rail and could raise costs, narrow shippers' options and weaken service.

It arrived on the last day for written public input. Under the procedural schedule the board adopted Aug. 18, comments, protests and requests for conditions in the case (Docket No. FD 36873) are due Nov. 18, and the railroads have until Feb. 16, 2027, to respond.

The senators also pointed to a recording of Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena. DTN reported Nov. 18 that Vena told a room of rail shippers last March he would probably raise rates 3% or 4% on companies that opposed the merger. The senators want the board to weigh whether threats like that keep shippers from speaking up. Union Pacific has called the remark offhand and says it does not retaliate against customers.

If approved, the deal would create the largest U.S. railroad and the first to serve both coasts, the Midwest Newsroom reported Nov. 18. DTN reported the same day that the combined system would reach 43 states and, citing The Wall Street Journal, would hold 39% of the rail freight market. Union Pacific told the Midwest Newsroom the merger would do away with slow handoffs between railroads at gateways such as Chicago, Kansas City and St. Louis.

What it means for carriers

The railroads are pitching the merger as a way to win freight from trucks. Their application projects about 2.1 million fewer truckloads a year on U.S. roads, the Midwest Newsroom reported Nov. 18. Those are loads truckers haul today.

Truck pricing still sets the bar for rail. "Trucks will always present essentially the ceiling on what we can do with pricing," Norfolk Southern chief strategy officer Mike McClellan told the Midwest Newsroom.

Trucking is not united on the deal. Schneider sent the board a letter of support, and Hub Group also backs the merger, the Railroad Weekly newsletter reported Nov. 15. Both rank among the largest intermodal companies. The newsletter said rival railroads BNSF and CPKC were preparing detailed objections, and DTN noted that the American Farm Bureau Federation helped launch the Stop the Rail Merger Coalition in April to fight the deal.

What shippers and brokers should watch

Nothing changes on the rails yet. The next steps:

- Dec. 3: The Justice and Transportation departments file their comments, DTN reported Nov. 18.
- Feb. 16, 2027: Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern answer the comments, under the board's Aug. 18 schedule.
- Spring 2027: Public hearings are expected, the Midwest Newsroom reported Nov. 18.
- May 28, 2027: Final briefs are due, with a board vote within 90 days after that, DTN reported Nov. 18.

Shippers and brokers with freight moving through the Midwest gateways should watch two things: whether the board attaches conditions meant to protect competition, and whether it acts on the retaliation complaints. Both bear on rail pricing in lanes where trucks are the main alternative.