Appeals court rules DOT wrongly withheld $73.5 million from New York over non-domiciled CDLs

A federal appeals court ruled Nov. 13 that the Transportation Department went beyond its legal powers when it withheld highway money from New York over commercial driver's licenses the state issued to immigrants.

The department held back $73.5 million in April and had threatened to withhold another $147 million a year, Reuters reported Nov. 13. A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration acted arbitrarily and capriciously when it penalized the state, the Associated Press reported Nov. 13. The decision was unanimous, FreightWaves reported the same day.

The fight was over non-domiciled CDLs, a class of license states issue to some immigrant drivers. FMCSA's 2025 review found New York substantially out of compliance because its non-domiciled CDLs could stay valid for as long as eight years, even when a driver's legal stay ended sooner, FreightWaves reported Nov. 13. About 32,600 people in New York held a non-domiciled CDL or commercial learner's permit, according to FreightWaves' Nov. 13 report. New York refused to revoke the licenses and sued in April, AP reported Nov. 13.

The judges looked at what the rules said at the time. FMCSA conceded that the regulation's plain text did not require a license's expiration date to match the driver's lawful-presence documents, and it could not cite any earlier case in which it had faulted a state on that point, FreightWaves reported. The agency argued its reading was common sense. The court said the decision broke fair-notice principles and strayed from the regulation's text, according to Reuters. AP reported that the panel found New York could not be blamed for failing to cancel licenses under cancellation rules that were not yet in place.

The Transportation Department said in a statement Friday that letting foreign drivers' licenses run years past their legal stay makes no sense, AP reported. "We've put a stop to the madness to keep the driving public safe," the statement said. New York had argued that revoking the licenses would disrupt industries that depend on commercial drivers, Reuters reported.

The case is one front in a wider federal push on who may hold a CDL. Non-domiciled licenses account for about 5% of all CDLs, or roughly 200,000 drivers, and about 26,000 drivers have been pulled off the road for failing to show English proficiency, AP reported Nov. 13.

What it means for carriers

The case turned on the rules in place before September 2025, FreightWaves reported Nov. 13. The rule that applies now is FMCSA's final rule on non-domiciled CDLs, published Feb. 13 and in effect since March 16, 2026, according to FMCSA. It limits non-domiciled CDLs and learner's permits to drivers with specific, verifiable employment-based nonimmigrant status, the agency says.

- Check every driver's license against the current rule, not the older one.
- Expect more court fights. A similar case between California and the federal government is pending in the D.C. Circuit, FreightWaves reported Nov. 13.

What shippers and brokers should watch

- Driver supply. New York never revoked the licenses FMCSA flagged, AP reported, so the ruling by itself does not add or remove drivers.
- Whether the Transportation Department asks the full 2nd Circuit or the Supreme Court to review the decision.
- Whether the department keeps using highway money to pressure other states over CDLs.